Public access radio that connects community members to one another and the world
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
Join KDNK for the Annual Meeting & Board Election on Monday, November 16th at 6pm!

Garfield County Library trustee candidates calling for more diverse board

Carbondale Branch Library
Katalina Villarreal
Carbondale Branch Library

Since March 2024, when the Garfield County Commissioners took control of the Garfield County Library board of trustees appointment process amidst controversy about certain books available at the library, 63 people have stepped up to be involved in library district governance.

Ten candidates vied for three positions in May 2024. Twenty-seven applied for three seats that December, but commissioners only appointed two. Then, four applied for the Glenwood Springs position, which was filled in March, 2025. In January 2026, twelve candidates applied for three positions.

Now, Garfield County Commissioners will choose from nine candidates, including Jamie LaRue, former executive director of the county library district, and members of the LGBTQ+ community who said the library board may not represent all patrons.

Ashley Stahl is a trans woman and the director of the local chapter of PFLAG, a volunteer-run support organization for the LGBTQ+ community and its allies. “I'm applying for the at-large seat because the decisions this board makes about books and access land hardest on my community, and right now, nobody who's an open part of it has a seat at the board,” she said.

Stahl added that library materials deemed controversial are often about the LGBTQ+ community. “The policies on the table, like a minor's card and locked shelving, would sweep far more than just a handful of titles. Nationally, queer books are the ones these policies hit hardest,” she explained. “Some of the people sitting in this room pushing these policies have gone after queer books by name repeatedly on the public record, and I know what these stories mean from the inside.”

Her vision for the library district includes access for marginalized populations such as the unhoused, drug users or people in recovery, sex workers and those coming out of jail. “What this vision would look like in practice is a full library card for every resident, regardless of whether they have a photo ID or a mailing address. Library service for people in the county jail and in remote parts of our county,” she said. “A social worker on staff. Narcan in every branch. Food, hygiene, and health supplies delivered by our health partners in the community.”

She added that she’d like to see a different code of conduct. “I'd also want a code of conduct that focuses on rules about behavior and drops rules that punish folks for being poor,” she said.

Jamie LaRue told the interviewing panel - which included all Commissioners and three library trustees - that all of the attempts to restrict or remove access to certain materials represent just 3% of library collections. “That 3% are things that reflect, kind of as Ashley was talking about, previously marginalized populations,” he explained.

LaRue added that a library is a repository of the human story but also reflects whoever chooses what to put on the shelves. “And for a long time, the book industry was just made up of straight white women, and thus they bought books that reflected that,” he said. “And then over the past maybe 15 years, some change has begun to happen in publishing. So again, 3% of the materials may reflect those new populations and all of the controversy is about that 3%.”

Candidate Mason Hostadt, a longtime county public health employee, stated that the library is a great equalizer and that the board should represent everyone. “ Anybody can go into the library and no matter who you are, you have the same access, right? You have the same access to the computers. You have the same access to a warm place in the winter, a cool place in the summer. You have access to the books that every other person who walks into the library has,” he said. “And so, it's really fundamental that we keep that at the forefront of the ways in which we think about the operation of the board.”

LaRue reminded the panel that society is changing and the library board has an opportunity to change with it. “Libraries reflect social change. But if you only have the freedom to speak about the things that everybody agrees about, then you don't have freedom of speech at all.”

Other candidates are Caleb Waller, Jenny Zetah and Tela Forehand for the Silt seat. Nina Price, Kristi Gill and current library board treasurer John Malonee for the at-large seat.

Update: The Garfield County Commissioners appointed Tela Forehand for the Silt seat and John Malonee for his second term as the at-large representative.

Amy Hadden Marsh’s reporting goes back to 1990 and includes magazine, radio, newspaper and online work. She has previously served as reporter and news director for KDNK Community Radio, earning Edward R. Murrow and Colorado Broadcasters Association awards for her work. She also writes for Aspen Journalism and received a Society of Professional Journalists’ Top of the Rockies award in 2023 for a story on the Uinta Basin Railway. Her photography has also won awards. She holds a Masters in Investigative Journalism from Regis University.