Public access radio that connects community members to one another and the world
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
Join KDNK for the Labor of Love Auction on Thursday, December 3 at the Old Thompson Barn!

Aspen Glen bald eagle buffer zone threatened

Bald eagles at their nest.
Steve Harding photo
Bald eagles at their nest.

The bald eagle buffer zone in Aspen Glen, a high-end subdivision along the Roaring Fork River between Carbondale and Glenwood Springs, was first put in place in 1992 when the Aspen Glen Planned Unit Development was approved. A pair of bald eagles nested in a tall Ponderosa pine for decades. In 2018, along came a storm that blew down the tree, destroying the nest.

Then, in 2021, the Garfield County Commissioners denied a request from Aspen Glen Golf Company to remove the nest, stating that wildlife studies of the area were incomplete.

“The county commissioners did agree that they wanted to keep the buffer for both the bald eagles that use the area as roosting habitat and fishing habitat and foraging habitat, and also in recognition that elk frequently use the area and that area provides critical winter habitat for those elk,” said Delia Malone, vice-chair of Roaring Fork Audubon. She and others, including Aspen Glen residents, have been regularly observing wildlife activity in the zone since January 2021. They presented results to the county in 2023, 2024 and 2025, reiterating the need for the buffer zone.

“We know that both the eagles and the elk, and all of the other critters find this area as refuge” she told KDNK.

But, the original agreement for the 1992 buffer zone did not include wildlife other than the eagles. And, now the Aspen Glen Golf Club has submitted another application to make changes to the buffer zone. Davis Farrar founded Western Slope Consulting, a land planning firm based in Carbondale, CO. He worked on the current application but is now retired. He told KDNK that he does not speak for the Aspen Glen Golf Club or anyone else. He calls the eagle nest buffer zone the ENBZ.

“The resolution did not speak to or was intended to speak to elk, deer or other wildlife, which came up in that hearing,” he said. “And the original approval language included language to the effect that in the event the tree and/or nest were destroyed and the eagles moved, and upon a favorable recommendation from CPW, that the ENBZ could be removed subject to approval by the county commissioners.”

The Wildlife and Habitat Assessment, prepared for the new application by Steve Dahmer of Rifle-based Environmental Solutions, Inc, focused on about 23 acres of the Bald Eagle Buffer Zone, east of the Colorado River. The assessment shows degraded habitat within the study area with limited forage for elk and deer and that local human activity is a deterrent to wildlife.The report adds that few deer and elk were observed within the study area during the assessment.

Malone said the condition of the forage may be poor but that’s not a good reason to build on it. “The elk rely on that habitat for winter critical range. To say that [it] is poor, it may be. On the other hand, building on top of it basically renders that useless, unusable to wildlife.”

As for bald eagles, the report recognizes the importance of the riparian corridor for hunting and foraging. But states that the study area is not suitable bald eagle habitat because it is too far above the river and has no trees for perching or nesting.

Malone disagrees. “Roaring Fork Audubon documented the continued use of the area by the female eagle and her new mate and the essential value of that reach of river to provide them with hunting and foraging habitat,” she said.

According to the Wildlife and Habitat Assessment, Dahmer collected data during weekly, random, daytime site visits between February 3 and June 30, 2023, and random monthly visits for the next two years. The study included samples of nocturnal camera trap images from February through March, 2023, and the same time period in 2025 plus reviews of scientific literature and historical research analysis.

Malone said Roaring Fork Audubon’s study is different.

“So in our weekly surveys for the past four years, we have specific points that we go to and we go for a specific time,” she explained. “I could send someone else out from a different organization and say, ‘Go do this’ and our results would be reproducible. That is a key factor in peer-reviewed science.”

Mary Jane Orman, spokesperson for the Aspen Glen Golf Club, said in a statement that the Club stands by Dahmer’s wildlife study and the new application.

Colorado Parks and Wildlife issued a letter in June, 2026, stating that the proposed changes to the buffer zone were warranted.

Malone said the buffer zone is vital, considering how the Roaring Fork Valley has changed since 1992. She adds that the Garfield County Commissioners saw that need five years ago.

“We have a different situation and I think they recognized that this property has become essential,” she said. “Yes, it may be not up to standards. Yes, the grasses and the vegetation may not be ideal. Regardless, because we've lost so much habitat to development, this remaining remnant is essential.”

The Garfield County Planning Commission hearing on the application, scheduled for October 28, was canceled. A new hearing has been set for January 27 of next year.

Amy Hadden Marsh’s reporting goes back to 1990 and includes magazine, radio, newspaper and online work. She has previously served as reporter and news director for KDNK Community Radio, earning Edward R. Murrow and Colorado Broadcasters Association awards for her work. She also writes for Aspen Journalism and received a Society of Professional Journalists’ Top of the Rockies award in 2023 for a story on the Uinta Basin Railway. Her photography has also won awards. She holds a Masters in Investigative Journalism from Regis University.